Martin taggart

---

1. Understand the Basics of a Small Claim
   A small claim is a legal process to resolve disputes over monetary amounts within a specific limit, typically up to £10,000 in England and Wales. It’s designed to be straightforward and often doesn’t require legal representation.

When filing a claim against a builder, typical issues include:

• Poor workmanship
• Incomplete work
• Breach of contract
• Refusal to fix defects

2. Determine If a Small Claim Is Suitable
   Before filing a small claim, consider whether your case qualifies:

• The dispute must involve a monetary value within the small claims limit.
• Your case should focus on tangible losses, such as repair costs or refunds.
• Ensure the builder has been given a chance to rectify the issue before proceeding.

3. Check Your Contract and Consumer Rights
   Review the contract you signed with the builder, including any terms about payment schedules, deadlines, and guarantees. Under the Consumer Rights Act 2015, services must be provided with reasonable care and skill. If the work doesn’t meet this standard, you may have grounds for a claim.
4. Try to Resolve the Dispute Amicably
   Before taking legal action:

• Contact the builder and explain the issue clearly.
• Request they fix the problem within a specific timeframe.
• Keep a record of all communication, including emails and text messages.

5. Use Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)
   Consider mediation or arbitration before filing a claim. Many builders are members of trade associations that offer ADR services, which can help resolve disputes without going to court.
6. Gather Evidence to Support Your Claim
   To build a strong case, collect the following evidence:

• A copy of the contract or agreement
• Photos or videos of the substandard work
• Quotes or estimates for repair costs from other builders
• Receipts or proof of payments made
• Correspondence with the builder (emails, letters, or texts)
• Witness statements, if applicable

7. Send a Formal Letter Before Action
   Before filing your claim, send a Letter Before Action (LBA) to the builder. This letter should include:

• A summary of the issue
• A request for compensation or remedial action
• A clear deadline for their response (usually 14 days)

An LBA demonstrates that you’ve given the builder an opportunity to resolve the matter and can strengthen your case in court.

8. File Your Small Claim
   If the builder doesn’t respond to your LBA or refuses to resolve the issue, file a small claim through:

• Money Claim Online (MCOL): For disputes in England and Wales.
• Local courts in Scotland or Northern Ireland.

Provide accurate details about the claim, the builder’s contact information, and the amount you’re seeking.

9. Pay the Filing Fee
   The cost of filing a claim depends on the amount you’re claiming. Fees range from £35 to £455 in England and Wales, and you may qualify for fee remission if you have low income.
10. Serve the Claim to the Builder
    Once your claim is filed, the court will notify the builder (the defendant). They have 14 days to respond or 28 days if they acknowledge the claim and intend to contest it.
11. Prepare for the Court Hearing
    If the builder contests the claim, a court hearing may be scheduled. To prepare:

• Organize your evidence in chronological order.
• Practice explaining your case clearly and concisely.
• Be ready to answer questions from the judge.

12. Attend the Hearing
    During the hearing:

• Present your evidence and arguments calmly and professionally.
• Avoid emotional language—focus on facts and losses incurred.
• Be respectful to the judge and other parties involved.

13. Possible Outcomes
    The judge may:

• Order the builder to pay compensation or cover repair costs.
• Rule against you if your evidence is insufficient.
• Suggest a settlement between both parties.

14. Enforce the Judgment If Necessary
    If the court rules in your favor but the builder doesn’t comply, you may need to take enforcement action, such as:

• Hiring bailiffs to collect the debt.
• Applying for a Charging Order against their property.
• Requesting a Third-Party Debt Order.

15. Prevent Future Issues With Builders
    Avoid future disputes by:

• Hiring reputable builders with strong reviews and references.
• Drafting a clear, detailed contract before work begins.
• Monitoring the work regularly and addressing issues promptly.

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What should I include in my Letter Before Action?
Clearly state the issue, provide evidence, and outline your desired resolution. Give the builder a specific timeframe (e.g., 14 days) to respond.

2. Can I claim compensation for stress caused by poor workmanship?
While small claims courts primarily address financial losses, you may be able to include damages for inconvenience in some cases.

3. How long does it take to resolve a small claim against a builder?
The process varies but typically takes a few months, depending on case complexity and court availability.

4. What happens if the builder doesn’t respond to the court claim?
If the builder ignores the claim, you can request a default judgment, which orders them to pay the amount claimed.

5. Do I need a lawyer for a small claim against a builder?
No, small claims are designed for self-representation, but legal advice can be helpful if the case is complex.

6. Can I claim for unfinished work?
Yes, you can claim for the cost of hiring another builder to complete or correct the work.

---

Conclusion
Making a small claim against a builder can seem daunting, but by following the right steps, you can effectively resolve disputes. Start by gathering evidence, attempting resolution through ADR, and filing a claim if necessary. With proper preparation and a clear case, you can hold the builder accountable and seek the compensation you deserve.

---